I tried playing to the chord already published here but I kinda couldn't get along 
with them. So, I tried to figure out how to RWALLY play this song. I think, these 
chords are pretty right!

Intro: C D Em D

CI (x32010@1)threw a wish in the well
DDon't (xx0232@1)ask me, I'll never tell
EmI (022000@1)looked at you as it fell
DAnd (xx0232@1)now you're in my way

CI'd (x32010@1)trade my soul for a wish
DPennies (xx0232@1)and dimes for a kiss
EmI (022000@1)wasn't looking for this
DBut (xx0232@1)now you're in my way

C (x32010@1)                     DYour (xx0232@1)stare was holding, ripped jeans - skin was showin'
EmHot (022000@1)night, wind was blowin' 
DWhere (xx0232@1)you think you're going, baby?

C (x32010@1)               DHey (xx0232@1)I just met you and this is crazy
Em (022000@1)                  DBut (xx0232@1)here's my number - so, call me maybe?

C (x32010@1)                    DIt's (xx0232@1)hard to look right at you, baby
Em (022000@1)                  DBut (xx0232@1)here's my number - so, call me maybe?

C (x32010@1)                 DHey, (xx0232@1)I just met you and this is crazy
Em (022000@1)                  DBut (xx0232@1)here's my number - so, call me maybe?

C (x32010@1)                    DAnd (xx0232@1)all the other boys try to chase me
Em (022000@1)                  DBut (xx0232@1)here's my number - so, call me maybe?

CYou (x32010@1)took your time with the call
DI (xx0232@1)took no time with the fall
EmYou (022000@1)gave me nothing at all
DBut (xx0232@1)still you're in my way

CI (x32010@1)beg and borrow and steal
DHave (xx0232@1)foresight and it's real
EmI (022000@1)didn't know I would feel it
DBut (xx0232@1)it's in my way

C (x32010@1)                    DYour (xx0232@1)stare was holding, ripped jeans - skin was showin'
EmHot (022000@1)night, wind was blowin'
D (xx0232@1)Where you think you're going, baby?

C (x32010@1)               DHey (xx0232@1)I just met you and this is crazy
Em (022000@1)                  DBut (xx0232@1)here's my number - so, call me maybe?

C (x32010@1)                    DIt's (xx0232@1)hard to look right at you, baby
Em (022000@1)                  DBut (xx0232@1)here's my number - so, call me maybe?

C (x32010@1)                 DHey, (xx0232@1)I just met you and this is crazy
Em (022000@1)                  DBut (xx0232@1)here's my number - so, call me maybe?

C (x32010@1)                    DAnd (xx0232@1)all the other boys try to chase me
Em (022000@1)                  DBut (xx0232@1)here's my number - so, call me maybe?

C (x32010@1)                 DBefore (xx0232@1)you came into my life
                    EmI (022000@1)missed you so bad, I missed you so bad
DI (xx0232@1)missed you so, so bad

C (x32010@1)                 DBefore (xx0232@1)you came into my life
                    EmI (022000@1)missed you so bad and you should know that
DI (xx0232@1)missed you so, so bad

C D Em D

C (x32010@1)                    DIt's (xx0232@1)hard to look right at you, baby
Em (022000@1)                  DBut (xx0232@1)here's my number - so, call me maybe?

C (x32010@1)                 DHey, (xx0232@1)I just met you and this is crazy
Em (022000@1)                  DBut (xx0232@1)here's my number - so, call me maybe?

C (x32010@1)                    DAnd (xx0232@1)all the other boys try to chase me
Em (022000@1)                  DBut (xx0232@1)here's my number - so, call me maybe?

C (x32010@1)                 DBefore (xx0232@1)you came into my life
                    EmI (022000@1)missed you so bad, I missed you so bad
DI (xx0232@1)missed you so, so bad

C (x32010@1)                 DBefore (xx0232@1)you came into my life
                    EmI (022000@1)missed you so bad and you should know that
DSo, (xx0232@1)call me maybe?