She Cried:Jay And The Americans. #5 in 1962. #1. A# And when I told her, G# I didn't love her anymore.. A# she cried. #2. A# And when I told her, G# her kisses were not like before.. F# she cried. CHORUS: F# G# I thought that our romance was over and done. F# G# But to her it had just begun. #3. A# And when I told her, G# another girl had caught my eye.. A# she cried. #4. A# And when I kissed her, G# a kiss that only meant goodbye.. A# she cried. (INTERLUDE:) OUTRO: C And when I told her A# I didn't love her anymore C She cried. A sixties smash from Kraziekhat.