This is how Eli actually plays it on acoustic...

Capo: 5

Intro: G

Verse 1:
         G (320003@1)                 D (xx0232@1)       EmNo (022000@1)you never were one for resting easy were ya
    C (x32010@1)                  G (320003@1)            DSo (xx0232@1)much that when they told me how you left us here behind
         G (320003@1)        D (xx0232@1)          EmThat (022000@1)I didn't even bat an eye believing
     C (x32010@1)                 G (320003@1)             DIn (xx0232@1)words I should have said to make you stay but couldn't find
          C (x32010@1)                  D (xx0232@1)                G (320003@1)       D (xx0232@1)    CIn (x32010@1)just hoped that road would one day watch you walk right back to me
                D'till (xx0232@1)then I'll be
C (x32010@1)   D (xx0232@1)        GJet (320003@1)black and jealous


Verse 2:
And I'll dare not let 'em know that now you're gone
How I'll still be a fool for the way we used to be
I just keep laughin' out loud and play along
As if I traded you for one the way you traded me
'Cause with your beat up bag and your laced up shoes
You walked right out the door
And I hit the floor
Jet black and jealous


Chorus:
        G (320003@1)name="chord_200232@1">D/F# Em (022000@1)name="chord_xx0232@1">D         C (x32010@1)G (320003@1)D (xx0232@1)Tell me how      was I to know
        G (320003@1)name="chord_320002@1">G/F# Em (022000@1)name="chord_xx0232@1">D         C (x32010@1)G (320003@1)D (xx0232@1)Tell me how      can I let go
        C (x32010@1)               DWell (xx0232@1)I know wherever you are tonight
     G (320003@1)       D (xx0232@1)     CYou (x32010@1)look just like a queen
               DStealing (xx0232@1)the scene
C (x32010@1)              GJet (320003@1)black and jealous

G (320003@1)name="chord_200232@1">D/F# Em (022000@1)name="chord_xx0232@1">D   C (x32010@1)G (320003@1)D (xx0232@1) (x2)

Verse 3:
And I bet by now you're rolling through Pittsburgh
Watching the rain in passing headlights
From some roadside corner booth
Still smiling 'bout the choices that you made
Hoping the clouds are breaking up ahead
Skies blue instead of grey
But if you get out there and you find
That it's not what you thought it'd be, remember me
Jet black and jealous


Repeat chorus

             C (x32010@1)                   DYeah (xx0232@1)if you get out there and you find
               G (320003@1)        D (xx0232@1)       C (x32010@1)              DThat (xx0232@1)it's not what you thought it'd be, come back to me

        G (320003@1)name="chord_200232@1">D/F# Em (022000@1)name="chord_xx0232@1">D   C (x32010@1)G (320003@1)DTell (xx0232@1)me how
Tell me how was I to know
Tell me how was I to know

End: Fade out (I end on a G)