NOTE: Other existing tabs have simplifications for guitar.
This is my attempt at transcribing the original chords
from the recording in the style of a fake book.

Intro
F#7  F#m7b5  EMaj7

Verse 1
                E
You're just too good to be true
              EMaj7
Can't take my eyes off of you 
              E7
You'd be like heaven to touch 
        A
I wanna hold you so much 
             Adim7
At long last love has arrived 
            E
And I thank God I'm alive 
                F#7            F#m7b5
You're just too good to be true 
              EMaj7
Can't take my eyes off of you

Verse 2
Pardon the way that I stare
There's nothing else to compare 
The sight of you leaves me weak 
There are no words left to speak 
So if you feel like I feel 
Please let me know that it's real 
You're just too good to be true 
Can't take my eyes off of you

Interlude
F#m7  B7  EMaj7
F#m7  B7  EMaj7  C#7#9

Chorus
           F#m7             B7(b9)
I love you baby and if it's quite all right 
           EMaj7            C#7
I need you baby to warm the lonely nights 
           F#m7  B7(b9)             EMaj7(#5)   C#7
I love you baby, trust in me when I say

          F#m7                 B7(b9)
Oh pretty baby, don't bring me down I pray 
          [ch]EMaj7/G#[/ch]            C#7
Oh pretty baby, now that I've found you stay 
           F#m7                  D7
And let me love you baby, let me love you

Verse 1 (key up)
                G
You're just too good to be true
              GMaj7
Can't take my eyes off of you 
              G7
You'd be like heaven to touch 
        C
I wanna hold you so much 
             Cdim7
At long last love has arrived 
            G
And I thank God I'm alive 
                A7              Am7b5
You're just too good to be true 
              GMaj7
Can't take my eyes off of you


parenthesized tensions in the chorus (#5, b9) are optional
and not always played, basically is the note C natural