There's a serious gap in Peter Cincotti chords on the web. Did this by ear, but it 
sounds ok to me:)Not sure bout the last bridge part, though...

       E                             A
Like April snow blowing around in Gramercy Park
     E                              B
the two of us were never meant to last
     E                                       A
you left your traces and drove away like a circus in town
     E                                      B
a three-ring show that comes and goes too fast

     C#m                  B
the best of friends have been divided by a kiss
                  F#m          B          E 
if we can't love again, I can always remenisce

A          (C)
cinderella beautiful
      C#m        A
this one is for you
     A               B              C#m
we almost made our fairy tale come true
A           (C)
happy ever after was
C#m B A
unavailable
                      F#m
now, two years after midnight
             A
I'm still thinking of those yesterdays
                      F#m
when I was prince charming
             A                   E
and you were cinderella beautiful

     E
you know I don't like Christmas
                     A
but thanks for the holiday card
          E                     B
I didn't know you moved so far away

      E
the winter months were the usual mess
      A
back here in new york
E                           B
every day another shade of grey

C#m
I'm doing fine
      B              A
but sometimes every now and then
                        F#m
I miss who I was with you
        B              E
and I wonder where he went

A          (C)
cinderella beautiful
      C#m        A
this one is for you
     A               B              C#m
we almost made our fairy tale come true
A           (C)
happy ever after was
C#m B A
unavailable
                      F#m
now, two years after midnight
             A
I'm still thinking of those yesterdays
                      F#m
when I was prince charming
             A                   E
and you were cinderella beautiful

       B                               E
and I know our time has come and gone away
             A             E
so why do I waste my nights
                F#m                  B
dreaming of a you and me that can never be again?


A           (C)
happy ever after was
C#m B A
unavailable
                      F#m
now, two years after midnight
             A
I'm still thinking of those yesterdays
                      F#m
when I was prince charming
             A                   E
and you were cinderella beautiful