The Chord progression on the other tab is correct, but Matt plays it like this.
Capo 4

Intro
INTRO
e|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|
B|------------------1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-----------------------------------------|
G|------------------2-2-2-2-2-2-2-2-----------------------------------------|
D|------0-0-2-3-2-0-2-2-2-2-3-3-3-3-----------------------------------------|
A|--3-3---------------------3-3-3-3-----------------------------------------|
E|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|

All palm muted and played through the verses, chorus is down strums, bridge is just 
single noting the chords

C Am F (intro)
I feel it in your eyes
There's pain that covers up these lies
Now you may look like me
But it seems you're really different on the inside
We used to keep our hearts safe
We kept them safe and locked away
But then we grew up learning
That life could serve us in a better way

C
And why?
I'm asking you why?

C Am F (intro)
So what happened to your eyes
I saw them wander just like mine
So how did we come to see so differently
After all this time

C
And why?
I'm asking you why?

C
And why?
I'm asking you why?

C
If the sheep know his voice then tell me what is the choice
For the ones who haven't heard and have no need to rejoice
F                         C
Father, help me understand
C
'Cause I am just like him and Lord he's just like me
We came from the same town and the same families
F                                   C
But now he, he just won't understand
C
Please Lord open up his eyes
Can You open up these eyes?

C
And why?
I'm asking you why?